8 June 2020
Wall Street missed the fact that Friday’s US jobs report misclassified up to 4.9 million workers as working, when they were actually jobless. But that’s what happens when you ignore the small print.
We focus on Brent as the global benchmark.
The market closed Friday up a further $5/bbl at $42.24bbl, as traders waited for Saturday’s planned OPEC+ meeting to decide on further output cuts.
They saw no need to focus on the fact that US oil producers are starting to ramp up output again, given today’s high prices, or on the boring details of supply and demand as shown in Reuters’ chart of US distillate demand:
“Lockdowns are easing in most of the major economies, permitting factories to resume operations; now the problem is the lack of household and business demand, which will weigh on diesel use through the rest of 2020…Manufacturing surveys show output continuing to slide, even as lockdowns relax, as businesses struggle with the build up of unsold inventories along the supply chain and low sales to end users.
We focus on the US S&P 500 Index as the world’s major stock market index.
The market closed Friday at 3193, up a further 150 points over the week, despite the increasingly negative news about the economy. The mainstream media is, however, starting to share our concerns over this disconnect, and the gap between performance by the broad mass of the stocks and a few Winners, as the Wall Street Journal reports:
- “Beneath the surface, much of the stock market is suffering, too. Most stocks are down this year, many by 20% or more. A few fortunate winners have generated big gains, fueling the misperception that losses have been minimal.
- Entire industries have been flattened: Earlier this week, airlines were down an average of 52% year to date; banks, 33%; energy, 32%; autos, 30%; consumer finance, 27%. Even utilities were down 5%.
The question for investors is therefore two-fold – do they believe that:
- The FAAANM companies discussed last week can really continue to support the entire market?
- Or that the broad mass of out-of-favour stocks will really see a V-shaped recovery by end-year?
We have, however, seen this type of market before, in 1973 and 1999. And neither period ended well for investors. Of course, this time may be different – but history suggests it usually isn’t.
We focus on the US 10-year rate, as this is the “risk-free” benchmark for global markets.
Interest rates soared during the week, with the 10-year rate jumping to 0.90% from last week’s 0.64%. As the chart shows, the key question for investors is whether the rate will take another giant leap and regain its recent peak at 1.35%? Or will it stabilise somewhere below that level, and then head lower again?
- The issue is therefore whether investors now believe in a quick and highly inflationary V-shaped rally, where consumers rush out from lockdown and spend, spend, spend to make up for lost time?
- Or will they remain cautious, spending mostly on essentials and worrying about their employment prospects?
The key indicator industries are likely to be those most beaten down – travel, leisure and associated businesses such as commercial property and construction.
Of course, they are unlikely to stay at today’s depressed levels forever. And percentage gains can look wonderful when starting from a low base – an auto dealer who sells 2 cars instead of 1 has just doubled her sales after all.
But bankruptcies are still taking place in these industries at an alarming rate, and caution seems the operative word.
US JOBLESS DATA
The US jobs reports can usually be guaranteed to create some interest, but Friday’s report was one for the history books.
President Trump rushed to the Rose Garden in the White House to claim it showed “We’ve made every decision correctly”. He also argued that George Floyd, who died in police custody in Minneapolis, would be “looking down right now and saying this is a great thing“, even though black unemployment actually rose from 16.7% to 16.8%.
This wasn’t the only cautionary note in the report, for those who bothered to read the small print. Every month, the Bureau of Labour Studies and Census Dept use two surveys to check the jobless position:
- The Establishment Survey counts workers who are being paid, and it showed a 13.0% jobless level
- The Household Survey interviews 60,000 households, and it showed a 16.1% jobless level
There will always be differences between the two surveys, but clearly these is a major problem at the moment, as the BLS warn:
“As happened in April and March, some people who were not at work during the entire reference week for reasons related to the coronavirus were not included in this category. Instead, they were misclassified as employed but not at work.”
They estimate 1.4m people were misclassified in March, as well as 7.5 million in April and 4.9 million in May. And as the chart confirms, the other key issue is that the absolute number of people out of work is at levels never seen before in the post-War period..
Our flagship service, The pH Report, gives you a global perspective on business-critical issues.
To request a sample copy and
find out more about subscribing
pH Outlook team
Paul Hodges is a Global Expert with the World Economic Forum: he speaks regularly at international conferences and writes for the Financial Times.
Contact Paul ►
Daniël de Blocq van Scheltinga Is Hong Kong-based with a background in investment/ corporate banking; he was the first foreigner to run an SOE’s finance department in China.
Contact Daniel ►
David Hughes is an expert on the Middle East, and worked in Saudi Arabia for 5 years.
Contact David ►
Paul Satchell understands financial markets, having been an equity analyst with several leading investment banks.
Contact Paul ►